The mysterious being known as Black Cilice has gained – if within an admittedly small scene – a surprising degree of popularity lately. Surprising if only because it is rare to see a project so uncompromising in its enigmatic status, and so dedicated to lo-fi output, garnering significant attention. Yet, in 2017, Black Cilice dropped the mesmerising Banished from Time through Iron Bonehead productions, one of the largest labels in underground extreme metal. The record has already seen several re-presses, and any time spent on Instagram will reveal a horde of users showing off their copy of the record’s distinctive and perfectly representative artwork. I’ve noted this before, but Black Cilice’s eerie, minimalistic artwork is one of the best examples of a band’s aesthetic matching its sound.
With the release of Banished from Time, Black Cilice were already one of the bands that had defined my experience of extreme metal in 2017. The album is equal parts emotionally devastating, enchanting, and haunting. I read Susan Sontag’s wonderful Illness as Metaphor last week, and one of the most distinctive images in the text (admittedly, an image she is critical of, for the metaphorical confusion it causes), is the nineteenth century image of the victim of tuberculosis; more beautiful, more transcendent, as closer to death. This is the image conjured up listening to Banished from Time; of the enchanting pallor and vitality of those so close to being drained of all life. On a cruder note, the album treads the fine line between being so captivating as to demand repeated replays, and so emotionally raw and challenging to preclude them. You will be wrung out by listening to it, but you’ll press play again each time.
I’d thought about trying to review Banished from Time, but was reluctant given the amount of press it has already garnered, and how close some of this press has come to actually detracting from the album. You end up wondering if these reviews were written by people who even looked at or listened to the record. This idiot notes he doesn’t know if Black Cilice lyrics are in English of Portuguese, or even consist of words, despite the lyrics being included in the record. He also describes the musicianship as ‘passable’, which is both irrelevant and untrue. This barely-literate fuck-up thought it worth publishing the line ‘Vocally, this release has plenty of vocals’, and suggests that the record is ‘straight black metal with some atmosphere added in’. Whatever this means, I don’t want to know. Or take this passage from this other useless cunt, which consists of taking a boring point and writing it in ever stupider ways:
‘Mysteries had a very strange production; it was an album that highlighted the strangeness of black metal. Sometimes I forget how strange black metal is as a genre. Any black metal fan who listens to the genre every day can sometimes forget how strange and inconvenient the sounds are the same of the bands produce. Mysteries was an album that highlighted the strangeness of black metal…’
If nothing else, it’s testament to the quality of Banished from Time that you still want to listen to it after exposure to these fucking morons.
Anyway, an entirely unexpected opportunity – indeed, an opportunity I thought would never arise – to see Black Cilice live arose recently. In December 2016, Black Cilice played its first live show, in the Netherlands. In March this year, a second show was announced, this time in London. By luck, my current research trip for my PhD coincided perfectly with the show, and I grabbed tickets as soon as they went on sale. Little footage is available of the Netherlands show, but of what I had seen, it was impossible that this evening could be anything other than perfect. It seemed appropriate that the day of the show I spent leafing through crumbling seventeenth century manuscripts, often written on cow-hide. These stories of the now-long dead, inscribed on the flesh of the dead, seemed an appropriate companion to the night’s morbid delights.
The show was at the Boston Music Room, a venue I was last at with two close friends in 2015 to catch Tombs and Black Anvil. It’s a small room attached to a pub. It seems to have windows, but they haven’t been open either time I’ve been there. The show featured, of course, the usual effluvia brought in by metal gigs: some fat bloke body-banging; an incredibly tall goth with enough spiky facial piercings to look like a tool-box, who was like one of those optical illusions of eyes that seem to follow you wherever you move, except he was directly between me and the stage regardless of where I stood; and some pretend-Viking who had spent all day braiding his equally long beard and hair.
The line-up had initially consisted of Folteraar, who also played Black Cilice’s first show, Nornahetta, and Black Cilice. I’m not sure for what reason, but Wode ended up replacing Folteraar. I was a bit disappointed at this. Folteraar is the one-man project of the depraved mind behind elite raw black metal label The Throat, and I thought that the raw brutality of the band’s sound would translate well to the stage. Folteraar, like Black Cilice and Nornahetta, also exist, if firmly within black metal, well away from the genre’s orthodoxies. Though less like the rest of the line-up, there was something meaningful in the inclusion of Wode, though. Their more traditional sound, more obviously rooted in the early 90s Scandinavian scene, offered a demonstration of where black metal began, before Nornahetta and Black Cilice showed us where it could go.
Wode’s set was unfortunately damaged by a complete fuck up by the sound guy. For half the set, nothing was audible – and I mean nothing – except the snare drum and vocals. Poor production has often barely hampered black metal, but Wode’s sound requires a degree of competence behind the mixing board. Wode blend intricate, majestic twin-guitar tremming with sections of dirty, mid-tempo grooves. The end result is often somewhat uneven, sounding like a blend of Dissection and Darkthrone. In other words, they haven’t got down the blend that drove Watain’s mid-career success. When the sound guy finally realised that the two guitarists and bass player on stage had actually been playing instruments all set, and that perhaps the idea was that these should be audible, Wode showed themselves to be a tight if not exceptionally exciting live band. Even with a decent mix, the band seem a little lacking. The higher register trem-picking was all excellent, but the mid-tempo sections lacked punch, failing to hit as hard as the band clearly want them to. There’s good stuff here, regardless, but it’d be good to see the band bring their sound together a bit more.
Unlike Folteraar, I was sceptical regarding Nornahetta’s ability to translate their sound on record to the stage. I’m a big fan of The Psilocybin Tapes, the CD collection Nornahetta released through Signal Rex last year, that compiles all their earlier material. The Psilocybin Tapes is defined, though, by its excruciatingly lo-fi quality. Riffs, vocals, and drums are all hard to discern in the swirling, dissonant chaos of the record. It’s fucking terrifying, but you also don’t really know what you’re listening to at times. Nornahetta are certainly a very different band live, but are no less terrifying. The band consists of two men, whose names are unknown, and who swapped between bass and guitar half-way through the set. For this reason, I have to refer to them as the short-haired one and the long-haired one. They were joined here by Trish Kolsvart on drums, from the fucking mental Asagraum. Trish is a fucking tight drummer: her playing has few frills, but she can blast for minutes on end, and has a rich sense of dynamics, crucial for Nornahetta’s sound live.
Nornahetta’s set opened with the short-haired member chanting on the ground, with the long-haired guy and Trish offering only minimal accompaniment. Slowly they built their way from this sparse introduction, through patient repetition and Trish’s increasing activity on the drum-stool, to a dissonant maelstrom. From this point, the set rarely deviated from blasting intensity. The effect, in particular because of the effects-laden guitar work, is hypnotic. Indeed, though Nornahetta’s songs aren’t especially long, one loses sight of these distinctions – as on record – watching them live, as you’re engulfed in the chaos. I remember songs ending and starting, but that all seemed peripheral. I experienced the set as a single, intense ritual. The main difference between live and on record is that there’s way more low-end in the sound; Nornahetta are fucking heavy live. The demented howls of both men contribute to this.
Honestly, I think they were tight, but this was a set that was experienced viscerally, in which such subjects rarely came to mind. I have one complaint, though minor, and again about the sound. When the guys swapped guitar and bass, they also swapped mics, changing from the ones they had sound-checked on. Clearly, the long-haired guy had a far louder voice, so his initial mic was set at a lower level than the short-haired guy’s. When they changed mics, though, this meant the long-haired member was now at the loud mic, and his vocals over-powered the entire band. This would’ve been an unbelievably easy fix for the stupid cunt doing sound. When they swap mics, you simply have to swap mic levels. Instead, he did nothing. It didn’t really detract from the set, but it was still fucking dumb.
Photos taken by Instagram user @earthreborn
Black Cilice, thank fuck, brought their own sound guy, whose contribution, as well as getting the mix to sound exactly the same as Banished from Time, was to have grown a handle-bar moustache that perfectly replicated the black lines on the corpse paint worn by Black Cilice’s live members. Black Cilice played live as a four-piece; a vocalist (I assume the band’s only real member), a drummer, and two guitarists – no bass player. The live sound was incredible, as the band perfectly captured the wobbly, trebly, reverb-laden guitar tone of Banished from Time. It should go without saying, but this emphasised the extent to which lo-fi doesn’t necessarily equate to a rejection of recording values. It reveals the extent to which Black Cilice’s particular brand of lo-fi recording is entirely intentional, carefully crafted to best reflect the music.
Black Cilice played an hour-long set, which consisted of – I think – all of Banished from Time, as well as some material from A Corpse, A Temple, and at least one track from Summoning the Night, the dissonant ‘Chaos and Evil’. The four members all wear the distinctive cloaks of Black Cilice’s artwork, with hoods pulled down well over their corpse-painted faces, which were rarely visible. The band was illuminated only by white back-lighting, and they played drenched in the dense fog of a smoke machine. The stage was foregrounded by elaborate candelabra, and the vocalist at one point held aloft a smaller candelabrum hanging from a chain. The otherworldly, mystical presentation of the band was perfect. Too many bands – particularly in black metal – just slap on some corpse paint and think their live performances worthy of being described as a ‘ritual’. In Black Cilice’s case, there was no such pretence: this was a ritual in the deepest sense, affirming the value of taking seriously what it is to perform live.
It’s difficult to find anything more to say that can actually convey the experience of watching Black Cilice live. Of course, the musicianship was precise, and the band’s haunting stage presence evoked the sound perfectly. The howled vocals were particularly harrowing; more ghastly, though no less chilling, for being live. The most interesting aspect of the set was that you get a far greater sense live of how post-punk Black Cilice’s sound can be. The more noticeable dynamic shifts live reveal that, from the sparse major chord melodies that crop up throughout Banished from Time, and the metronymic drumming of the non-blasting sections, Black Cilice share much with that other no-less chilling and depressive genre. This isn’t a huge surprise: Black Cilice have released a split with Forbidden Citadel of Spirits, who in turn share members with Carved Cross, who in turn share members with Night Falls Haunting. As I’ve noted elsewhere, those latter two bands are very clearly influenced by post-punk. Witnessing the band live, one thus gets a slightly richer sense of how mesmerising Black Cilice are; of the diverse ways in which this dark magic is deployed.
Ultimately, watching Black Cilice was a transcendent experience; inspiring and moving. Black Cilice’s discography stands as a declaration to total dedication, the rotten fruit of allowing one’s darkest aspects to fester and slowly bloom. In its live incarnation, the band reveals that same dedication, a commitment to conceive of one’s band as a total project, in which the performance and music are one. Few bands will release music as good as Black Cilice’s, but fewer still will be able to perform it in a way that captures it and even enhances it to such an extent.